Security Monitoring & Security Service provider Ireland
Top Security, Physical and Virtual - Securing Monitoring Protecting - Nationwide 24hrs x 365 days a year
ABOUT US
CONTACT US
SERVICES
PRODUCTS
SALES
PRESS
GARDA POLICY
CUSTOMER LOGIN
CAREERS
USEFUL LINKS
FEEDBACK
SITE MAP



 
Subscribe to our security newsletter

Alarm Companies
General
 
SECURITY SURVEYS

Business Crime Costing SMEs €1.5bn Per Annum

Download PDF

  • One-third of SMEs have been the victim of crime in the last 12 months.
  • 75% of effected enterprises experienced more than one instance of crime.
  • 70% of business owners believe that crime levels are getting worse.
  • A paltry 3% feel that the judicial system is effective.
  • Tougher court sentencing and increased Garda presence demanded.
  • Separate recording of business crime urgently needed.

 ISME, Friday, May 25th, 2012.

The NATIONAL CRIME SURVEY (sponsored by Top Security Ltd.) issued today (May 25th 2012), by ISME, the Irish Small & Medium Enterprises Association, confirms that the annual cost of crime is now €1.5bn. The survey reveals that while the number of enterprises affected by crime has reduced slightly, the number of incidents and the costs of crime against business have increased in the last 12 months. The Association called on the Government to prioritise business crime, an area that has not, to date, received the attention it warrants.

The results of the survey, which attracted a response from 648 businesses, confirms that in the last 12 months, one third of companies (32%), have been the target of criminal activity. Construction (61%) and the Retail (44%) sector were the areas of the business community most affected.

Regionally, the highest incidence of crime was reported in Dublin County and Ulster (40% each) closely followed by Dublin City 39%, Rest of Leinster 33% and Connacht 19%.  

The total cost of crime per enterprise has risen by 59% since 2007. This figure is a composite of the actual loss suffered, repairs required and the annual cost of prevention. While the cost of prevention has reduced by 7% since 2007 to €4,193, the direct costs have increased by a massive 130% to €9,640 per enterprise since 2007.

The total direct cost of crime against business in the last 12 months is estimated at €1.455bn, (calculated on 200,000 businesses in Ireland compared to 233,000 in 2011). This does not take into account the indirect costs of crime on the business, including poor staff morale, business disruption and in some cases relocation.

Key issues that are highlighted include:

  1. 70% reported that they felt that the general level of crime has increased in the last 12 months, up from 66% in 2011.
  2. Half of businesses (50%) stated that, in their opinion, the problem of crime in their own locality was getting worse, up on the 46% figure in 2011 and significantly more than the 30% in 2010.
  3. 67% identified the recession as the main reason for increased crime levels up from 60% in 2011.
  4. The most common crime reported was 'Burglary' by 39% of respondents, closely followed by 'Robbery' 38%, ‘Vandalism' 32% and ‘Attempted Burglary’ 25%.
  5. Sectorally, Construction reported the highest incidence of crime with 61% confirming that their businesses had experienced crime in the last 12 months. Retail reported the next highest level of crime at 44%, while IT Services reported the lowest level at 12%.
  6.  Only 8% of respondents were confident that the perpetrators would be apprehended.
  7. Of those who reported incidents to Gardai, 74% felt that the issue was dealt with adequately or effectively, while 26% were dissatisfied with the response, down from 21% in 2011.
  8.  An overwhelming 84% expressed a lack of confidence in the judicial system, with only 3% expressing confidence. This is not surprising as 70% of companies would encourage tougher sentencing by the Courts as a deterrent to business crime.
  9. 3 out of 4 SMEs would be in favour of increasing Gardai numbers and Gardai presence on the streets, while 67% support increased CCTV in town centres.

The survey results confirm that the full extent, impact and cost of crime against business are not properly recorded, as a significant number of companies (20%) do not report crime to the authorities. There are a number of factors contributing to this situation, including a perception among small business owners that crimes against their businesses are not viewed as real crime and therefore are not taken seriously. Also only 8% of small business owners surveyed had confidence that if they were a victim of crime, the criminal would be apprehended.

The SME community have lost faith in the ability of the judicial system to protect them, with only 3% having faith in the judiciary. This figure has remained this low for a number of years with absolutely no effort forthcoming from our well paid judiciary to rectify the situation.

It should also be noted that business crime statistics are not recorded separately, indicating once again that crimes against business are not treated as seriously as crimes against the individual, this despite the fact that businesses are twice as likely to be the victims of crime as individuals.

Instead of investing in capital or labour, precious resources are frittered away on rectifying criminal damage, crime prevention measures and higher insurance costs. In extreme cases the incidence and cost of crime can threaten the viability of the business. Some of the costs of the crimes incurred by businesses will be passed on to consumers. If businesses are forced to relocate from a particular area because of the prevalence of crime, then local customers are deprived of the businesses’ services and potential employees lose the work opportunities.

Commenting on the findings, ISME Chief Executive, Mark Fielding, outlined, “This year’s crime statistics highlight the need to establish a robust crime reduction strategy with key performance indicators to measure the success of any implementation measures. Business crime has long been seen as a victimless crime, however it has a devastating effect on jobs, livelihoods and whole communities.”

“Small business believe that the authorities, both legislature and judiciary, have ineffectively dealt with the scourge of business crime locally and nationally. A properly resourced Crime Prevention Office with specialists in business crime would reduce the €1.5bn bill that SMEs face annually in terms of direct crime costs and prevention.” 

“Business owners will continue to postpone or cancel investment in their company until sufficient action is taken against the perpetrators of business crime. Small business needs action now in terms of enforcement and a more visible presence of Gardai on our streets,” he added.

Emmet O’Rafferty, Chairman of Top Security, said, “From our experience, many smaller businesses are not reporting crimes because they either have no insurance or are fearful of rising insurance premiums.  Inadequate security leaves a business vulnerable to crime and the financial and psychological impact can suck the energy out of a small business very quickly, thereby threatening its very existence. The peace of mind that good security brings is worth the minimal investment when compared to the post-crime costs.” 

To address the ever increasing levels of business crime, ISME recommends the following initiatives:

  1. The establishment of a National Forum on Crime with a specific mandate to investigate the extent and impact of crime against business and to propose a solution. This forum should be made up in the main of representatives from the law enforcement agencies and representatives of the business community.
  2. The State must introduce a proper recording system to establish the level of crime against business to identify the extent, nature and scope of the problem. Specific figures outlining crime against business should be included in the Annual Report of the Garda Commissioner.
  3. Key performance indicators should be used to gauge the effectiveness of a crime reduction strategy.
  4. There needs to be a radical reassessment by the judiciary of crime against business and a commitment to stronger sentences for those crimes to ensure that proper mandatory sentences are handed down, with the sentence fitting the crime.
  5. Reduce the length of time it takes for cases to be heard in Court.
  6. Continue increasing the number of Gardai in public view and on patrol, by freeing them up from administrative duties which can be contracted out to the private sector.
  7. Redirect sufficient resources to the Crime Prevention Office of the Gardai to increase awareness of the role of the Office and the advantages of liaising with the CPO.
  8. Retain and improve community policing. This should include adequate training and insight into how local businesses operate and the impact and extent of business crime.
  9. Increase the level of CCTV surveillance particularly in town centres, as this is a proven deterrent to criminal activity.
  10. More emphasis should be put on the development and implementation of business watch initiatives with 'best international practice' being introduced.

In conclusion ISME demanded that the Government crackdown on business crime by implementing ISME’s recommendations and adopting a tougher stance with the perpetrators.

The Top Security sponsored ISME National Crime Survey Report is attached and available for download at www.topsecurity.ie

ISME is the independent voice of Small & Medium business in Ireland, representing in excess of 8,750 members across all sectors. The Association is owned and run by owner managers and is independent of big business, government and unions; ISME the TRUE voice of the SME.

 

 

An evening with
Joanne O'Riordan

Hosted by
Top Security
spacer
Customer Testimonials
Read customers' experience with our service

Read More »
spacer
Change of Details Form
This form enables our customers to request changes to account details.

Read More »
spacer
Security Shop
Our recommended security products

Browse Shop »
spacer
TopLocate
Personal Security Monitoring

Read More »
spacer
Press Archive
Top Security press archive

Read More »
The Fr. Frank Maher
Classical Music Awards

Sponsored by
Top Security

Copyright © 2013 Top Security - Top Security, diverse and cutting edge in our security offerings

TopMail   BlockMail   TopLocate